If you’ve spent any time scrolling social media in the last decade, you’ve probably run into Fabletics. It’s the activewear brand behind all those soft leggings, color-coordinated sets, and a VIP membership that gives members a monthly credit to spend on clothes (and lower prices).
The only problem for me is that they have so many colors, cuts, and matching sets that I’ll add a dozen things to my cart and not actually be able to decide between them. The other problem is that I know exactly what I like, so I keep gravitating toward variations of the same leggings and tops.
That’s why their new Mystery Box appealed so much to me. It sounded like a fun way to let someone else choose a few pieces I might have overlooked — almost like handing the shopping decisions to a stylist, minus the appointment.
Here’s how it went for me!
How the Fabletics Mystery Box Works

First things first, the Mystery Box is a limited-time offer for Fabletics VIP members. If you’re not already in the club, the program is $69.95/month (which you can put on hold) and includes a VIP Credit and additional benefits like member pricing, exclusive outfits, and other offers. However, the Mystery Box is a separate purchase (another $69.95), which means you can’t use your VIP Credit to buy it.
When ordering a Mystery Box, you start by entering your top, bottom, and bra sizes separately. You can also choose a short, regular, or tall inseam, which I appreciate because the length of leggings and pants can make a big difference in how they look and feel.
After sizing, you get to share your style preferences. Color options include warm colors, cool colors, neutrals, prints, and Surprise Me. You can also select clothing categories, including tops, bras, leggings and pants, shorts and skirts, and dresses or one-pieces. I went with Surprise Me for both; I was hoping for something a little different.
Keep in mind that the Mystery Box is an all-sales-final kind of thing, so I’d pay attention to the sizing and preferences before checking out, especially if you’re between sizes or know there are certain styles you rarely wear.
What Was in My Mystery Box

My box contained four clothing items:
- Shawl Collar Puffer Shine Jacket, Black Shine, small
- High-Waisted Crossover Flare Pants, Midnight, medium
- Katrina Low Impact Sports Bra, Red Apple, small
- Everyday Quarter Crew Socks, Bone / Classic White, labeled one size
There was also a black Fabletics tote, a VIP surprise card, and a QR-code insert offering a chance to win a $100 credit.
The assortment gave me something for going out, something for Pilates, a comfortable bra, and socks I’d wear with practically anything.
Shawl Collar Puffer Shine Jacket: My Favorite Surprise

I really only expected activewear in my box, so the jacket immediately caught my attention and was the first thing I wanted to try on.
It’s black with a shiny finish, rounded shoulders, a cropped length around the hip, and a generous shawl collar. That collar gives it a dressier look than my typical outdoor jacket, and I could immediately picture wearing it with more than workout clothes.
I’ve worn it twice so far: once to dinner with my husband and once on a cold walk. It’s surprisingly lightweight for how warm it kept me outside, and the shell is water-resistant. The zippered pockets are another feature I appreciate, especially when I’m carrying my phone and keys and don’t want to bring a bag.
My small fits nicely over a long-sleeve top, although I’d consider sizing up if I wanted to wear chunky sweaters underneath. There’s no hood, so I’d grab a hat for a windy Michigan day, but I love the look of the shawl collar.
I tend to gravitate toward more understated jackets, and this one has a little more personality. It looks cute with leggings and sneakers, but I also liked how it dressed up my casual dinner outfit. I might have scrolled right past this jacket while shopping online, but I’m glad it was picked for me.
High-Waisted Crossover Flare Pants: My Favorite to Wear

I tried these on the day my box arrived and wore them to Pilates that week. They’re a deep Midnight color, with a crossover waistband and a flare that gives them a different look from the leggings I usually wear.
As a millennial, skinny jeans and fitted leggings have had a chokehold on me for years. I’m trying to grow with the times, though, and these flare pants are making that transition a lot easier. I actually love how they look with sneakers, and the slightly more relaxed silhouette is a fun change from everything tapering around my ankles.
The fabric feels soft and slightly brushed, almost velvety against my skin. I do already have the Fabletics PowerHold leggings, which are much more compressive, so I liked having something softer for a lower-impact class. They still look put together enough that I’ve worn them outside of Pilates too.
I was particularly curious about the crossover waistband because I’ve tried similar styles that look great standing still but need adjusting once you start moving. During Pilates, this one stayed in place through roll-ups, and I didn’t spend the class pulling it back up.
The medium fits me well overall. I sometimes prefer a large when I’m shopping specifically for relaxed, comfort-first leggings, but I’m happy with the fit of these. I’ve been washing them cold and hanging them to dry, and so far they’ve maintained their shape. I’ll keep an eye on how the fabric and seams hold up with more wear.
I also appreciate the different inseam options Fabletics offers. With flared pants, the length makes a difference because I want them to fall nicely over my shoes without dragging on the floor. These have become my pick for Pilates days when I want something softer than my compression leggings. I’m certainly not giving up my PowerHold pairs, but apparently there’s room in my closet for a little less skinny and a little more flare.
Katrina Low Impact Sports Bra: Comfortable, but Not for Running

The Katrina bra arrived in Red Apple, and it is BRIGHT. I’m usually drawn to colors that coordinate easily with my other activewear, so I probably wouldn’t have chosen this particular shade myself. But that was part of the fun of ordering the Mystery Box, and I actually like how the red looks with the darker bottoms I already own.
I wore it to Barre first, which felt like a good place to try a low-impact bra. The SculptKnit fabric is smooth and stretchy, with a wide band that sits comfortably against my ribs. My small fits well without feeling overly restrictive.
What I appreciate most is that I don’t feel like I need to change out of it immediately after class. I’ve worn it around the house on relaxed weekends, too, and it’s comfortable enough to keep on for hours. Some of my more supportive sports bras are great during a workout, but I can’t wait to take them off afterward. The Katrina is much easier to lounge in.
Of course, that softer feel comes with lighter support, which is exactly what I’d expect from a low-impact bra. I have a smaller bust and can sometimes get away with less structure, but I still wouldn’t choose this one for running or jumping; that’s when I reach for my more supportive sports bras. For Barre, lounging, and days when I’m not doing anything particularly strenuous, the Katrina has been a comfortable addition to my drawer.
Everyday Quarter Crew Socks: The Boring Item I Keep Wearing

I didn’t exactly squeal over the socks. Next to a shiny jacket and bright red bra, a pair of off-white quarter crews doesn’t make much of an entrance. But considering I have a drawer full of single socks whose partners have apparently left home to start new lives, a fresh matching pair was probably something I needed more than I realized.
And yet, I’ve worn them more often than anything else in the box. They’re thin and breathable rather than heavily cushioned, which is what I tend to prefer for everyday sneakers. They have enough stretch to stay up without slipping down, and they’re comfortable for running errands or just spending the day around the house.
After a bunch of washes, I’ve noticed they’re already starting to look a little fuzzy. That’s normal for most of the socks I own, so I’m curious to see how they hold up over time compared to my other brands.
Who Should Try the Fabletics Mystery Box?

The Mystery Box is great for anyone who already enjoys Fabletics and likes experimenting with different styles. If you tend to gravitate toward the same leggings and tops every time you shop, it can be fun to let someone else choose a few things for you.
The final-sale policy is the main consideration. Being able to enter separate sizes helped me, and I was happy with how everything fit, but there’s always some variation between different clothing styles. My jacket, for example, fits nicely over a regular top, although I’d want more room if I planned to wear thick sweaters underneath.
I’d also think about what you’re shopping for. If you specifically need black leggings with pockets or a high-support running bra, I’d buy those items directly. I still love choosing my own matching sets, especially when I have a particular workout or color in mind.
I also think it could make a cute gift for someone who already likes the brand. You’ll definitely need to know their sizes and preferences before ordering, since it’s final sale, but for a friend who loves activewear and could use a little variety, I think the surprise would make it feel more personal than a typical clothing gift.
If you want a quick pros/cons list to help you decide, here are my thoughts in a nutshell:
Pros
- Gives you nice variety minus the decision-making
- Separate sizing for tops, bottoms, and bras, plus short, regular, or tall inseams
- You can set color and category preferences, or pick Surprise Me
- Comes with a reusable Fabletics tote
- Good value, with four pieces for about the price of one or two items bought separately
- A mix of workout clothes, everyday basics, and something you can wear out (at least in mine)
Cons
- All sales are final, so no returns or exchanges if something doesn’t fit or isn’t your style
- Only VIP members can buy it, and it’s a separate purchase you can’t use your VIP Credit on
- Fabletics doesn’t guarantee it will match your color or category preferences
- It’s a limited-time offer, so it isn’t always available
Would I Buy Another Fabletics Mystery Box?

Absolutely. I liked having someone else choose for once, and I ended up with a few things I probably wouldn’t have picked myself. The shiny black jacket is the perfect example; I don’t know that I would have clicked on it while shopping, but I’ve already worn it out to dinner and on a cold walk, and I love it.
Between that jacket and my new flare pants slowly convincing my millennial brain that skinny leggings aren’t the only option, I’d say the experiment worked. I still enjoy choosing my own matching sets, but I’d happily let Fabletics surprise me again — especially if there’s another jacket like that waiting inside.
At $69.95, I think the Fabletics Mystery Box was a great deal for the pieces I received. The jacket and Pilates pants were the biggest wins for me, and they’re both things I could easily see myself buying separately. Getting a sports bra and socks in the same box made the assortment even better.
I also liked that the pieces were different enough to give me some variety; I got something to wear out to dinner, something for Pilates, and a couple of everyday basics. For the price, I was really happy with that combination.
- Is the Fabletics Mystery Box Worth It? My Review After Wearing Everything - November 20, 2026
- Fabletics vs Vuori: Which Activewear Brand Should You Buy in 2026? - November 8, 2026
