5 Best Kitty Litter Subscriptions

Every cat parent has made that emergency late-night run to the drugstore when they realize *gasp*… they’re out of litter!

Kitty litter subscriptions eliminate that annoying experience by delivering litter to your door on a pre-determined (ideally flexible) basis. But not all kitty litter subscriptions are equal.

These are the five best kitty litter subscriptions available on the market today.

The Best Kitty Litter Subscriptions

1. GreatLitter (4.5/5)- Best budget-friendly subscription litter
2. Kitty Poo Club (4/5)- Best all-in-one litter and disposable box
3. PrettyLitter (5/5)- Best health-monitoring color-changing litter
4. Tuft & Paw Really Great Cat Litter (4/5)- Best premium, eco-friendly subscription litter
5. Skoon Cat Litter (4/5)- Best natural, non-clumping litter with odor control

How I Chose These Kitty Litter Subscriptions

I curated this list based on a few different criteria to make sure that I had options for every cat parent’s budget and unique needs. I wanted to find subscriptions that were flexible with litter formulas that were effective and a good value.

Some of the things I looked for were:

• Odor Control & Absorption–  I wanted litters that master the art of odor control and absorb maximum moisture to keep homes smelling fresh. Your litter should trap odors immediately and not get too stinky between cleanings.
• Subscription Flexibility– I looked for services that offer customizable delivery schedules and easy skips and cancellations. I included options that offer solutions for every household, no matter how many cats they have.
• Material & Sustainability– I considered more eco-friendly options, including plant-based, biodegradable, and low-dust formulas to minimize ecological impact. These safer materials come with the added benefit of being better for your health, as low-dust and additive-free formulas are less likely to cause respiratory distress or health issues.
• Cat & Owner Convenience– I looked at how easy the litter is to scoop, clean, and get cats to use. A good litter should be easy and low-stress for cat owners and usable and comfortable for the cats themselves.
• Value for Money– I compared pricing, quantity, and overall quality to make sure all of these subscription options provide a good deal. The pricier litters on the list are truly worth it for those with the budget.

1. GreatLitter

Best budget-friendly subscription litter

GreatLitter is an affordable kitty litter subscription service that provides reliable odor control at a better price. 

It’s a clumping clay formula designed to work with your Litter Robot (though it still works in regular litter boxes, too). It’s very easy to scoop, the subscription means you’ll never run out, and the reasonable price point makes it a good option for multi-cat households. 

Unfortunately, it doesn’t have quite as many premium features as other brands here, and its lightweight formula can sometimes lead to tracking.

Price: $30 for one 20lb bag per month.

Pros

• Affordable subscription option
• Good odor control for the price
• Available for multi-cat households
• Works well with a Litter Robot

Cons

• May track more than premium brands
• Fewer advanced features
• Some formulas may be dustier than others

2. Kitty Poo Club

Best all-in-one litter and disposable box

Kitty Poo Club’s subscription is unique. It includes both high-quality litter and a disposable litter box. They have many different litter types available, including silica, clay, and natural alternatives, making it a versatile option for cat owners.

The disposable litter box makes cleanup super easy, and the subscription gives you one less thing for your to-do list.

While it’s incredibly convenient, the price is higher than traditional litter and a regular, reusable litterbox. Some cats may also take time to adjust to the disposable box design.

Price: from $28 per month for one standard cardboard box and one 15lb bag of litter

Pros

• Includes disposable litter box for easy cleanup
• Multiple litter types to choose from
• Monthly deliveries
• No litterbox cleaning necessary since you just throw it away
• Eco-friendly options available

Cons

• More expensive than regular litter
• Your cat might not like the disposable box

3. PrettyLitter

Best health-monitoring color-changing litter

PrettyLitter is a silica-based litter that actually changes color to indicate potential health issues in cats. This feature sets it apart from other subscriptions, making it the best choice for pet owners who want insight into their cat’s health. 

PrettyLitter also offers strong odor control and causes less tracking, which are two of the most important features in a litter (at least to me). 

The only issue is that it doesn’t clump like traditional clay litters, which could be new for some cat owners. It’s also important to state that the health monitoring feature is not a substitute for regular vet checkups.

Price: from $24 for 8lbs delivered every 4 weeks

Pros

• Color-changing formula detects potential health issues
• Lightweight and easy to deal with
• Good odor control
• Low tracking and dust-free

Cons

• Doesn’t clump, so you need to use a different cleaning method
• Pricier than traditional clay litter
• Health detection not always 100% accurate

4. Tuft & Paw Really Great Cat Litter

Best premium, eco-friendly subscription litter

Tuft & Paw’s Really Great Cat Litter is a top-of-the-line, plant-based litter for cat owners who want a sustainable, low-dust, and high-performance option. 

This one is actually made from biodegradable soybean fibers that form tight clumps for easy scooping while providing exceptional moisture absorption and odor control without any artificial additives. 

Be warned, it’s kind of pricey, but the eco-friendly formula, minimal dust, and gentle texture for paws make it a great option for both cats and their owners. This is a high-quality, natural litter that prioritizes sustainability.

Price: $29 for one 9lb bag per month

Pros

• Eco-friendly, plant-based, and biodegradable
• Low-dust and easy on paws
• Strong odor control with all-natural ingredients

Cons

• More expensive than traditional litter
• Clumps slightly softer than clay litter
• Only available with subscription (so no running out for a last-minute bag if you’re low)

5. Skoon Cat Litter

Best natural, non-clumping litter with odor control

Skoon Cat Litter is a natural, non-clumping litter made from super absorbent diatom pebbles. 

It’s truly amazing at odor control yet also lightweight and dust-free, making it a good option for cat owners who may be looking for a natural alternative to traditional clay litter. 

Skoon’s subscriptions are the most customizable, allowing you to specify the type of litter you like and how many cats you have. You can skip or cancel at any time.

Skoon’s specialized low-maintenance formula means you only need to replace it once a month, which is great for busy cat owners.

The one negative is that it’s a bit more expensive than standard clay litter, and some cats might take time to adjust to the texture of the pebbles.

Price: $26.95 for one 8lb bag per month

Pros

• Highly absorbent and controls odor well
• Natural and chemical-free formula
• Low dust and lightweight
• Less scooping required than clumping clay litter

Cons

• More expensive than a traditional litter
• Non-clumping formula may not be your cat’s favorite 
• Some cats might need time to adjust to the different texture

So, Which Kitty Litter Subscription Is the Best?

It’s hard to definitively answer which kitty litter subscription is the best one, as different cat owners have different needs. If you’re on a tighter budget or have a Litter Robot, you should definitely check out the affordable GreatLitter subscription. And for the added benefit of health monitoring, look into PrettyLitter.